Wrought iron, steel or aluminum for an Austin gate

Nothing sold as a wrought iron gate today was hammered out of puddled iron, and the fabricators who have logged teardowns for austin iron gates preflight sim see the same mild steel inside nearly every one. The choice that matters for a gate in Austin, TX comes down to three metals: steel, aluminum, and the small amount of real wrought iron that still turns up on older properties.
What wrought iron actually is

Real wrought iron has slag stringers running through it like wood grain, which gives it a fibrous look when broken and a good record against rust. It stopped being made in volume long ago. The gates called wrought iron now are almost always low-carbon steel bar and tubing, forged or bent into scrolls. An original gate on an old Austin lot is worth repairing before anyone talks about replacing it, because the metal itself is often better than anything sold new.
Steel, the working default

Steel tubing is easy to buy, stiff, and welds cleanly with ordinary equipment. A square tube frame with a picket infill carries a swing gate for decades if the finish is kept whole. The weak point is not the metal but the coating. Austin summers of 90F or more on over 120 days a year bake paint, and rain spread through the year keeps scratches wet long enough to start rust at the first bare spot. A galvanized or powder coat finish buys the most time.
Aluminum and its trade-offs
Aluminum does not rust, and it is far lighter than steel, which is easy on hinges, a gate opener and the carriage of a slide gate. It also dents, flexes more under the same section, and needs a different weld process with a clean joint and the right filler wire. For a tall privacy panel in the wind that comes off open ground near Lake Austin, aluminum needs a heavier section than the drawing suggests.
Weight, hinges and the operator
The metal sets what hangs on the post. A heavy steel dual swing gate wants thick hinge posts and a hydraulic operator sized for the leaf. A lighter aluminum frame lets a smaller actuator do the same job. Whichever metal is picked, the operator rating should be checked against the finished leaf weight, not the catalogue weight of the bare frame, and a battery backup or solar panel adds load of its own to the post.
Matching metal to the job
A front walk gate in a Hyde Park yard, opened by hand, suits steel with a good coat. A long cantilever gate across a wide drive suits aluminum or a lightened steel frame. Near Shoal Creek and the shaded ravines in the hills, damp ground holds moisture against the bottom rail, so a galvanized lower section or a raised bottom rail is worth the extra hour in the shop.